Pdf this chapter provides a comprehensive overview of the theoretical and empirical literature on the regulation of natural monopolies. Regulation not only fails to counter monopoly pricing, but is to the contrary used to sustain it. Monopoly is an important concept to this article but even more important is the related but somewhat less familiar concept of natural monopoly. What then is the appropriate competition policy for a natural monopoly. From 1963 to 1965, he was assistant to commissioner philip elman of the federal trade commission. Apply the analytical frameworks discussed in richard posner s theories of economic regulation to a specific federal regulation or area of federal regulation. He showed that there is a theoretical inconsistency in natural monopoly theory. Natural monopoly and its regulation book, 1999 worldcat. Natural monopoly and its regulation semantic scholar. Natural monopoly will occur only because of either specific market conditions or because of a unique product. Posner natural monopoly and its regulation pdf document.
Although the traditional view suggests that government intervention and natural monopoly go hand in hand, economic analysis since the late 1960s has suggested rather forcefully that there are ways to introduce competition for a market, even if a natural monopoly structure exists. The traditional rationale for economic regulation of the electric utility industry is the existence of natural monopoly. Natural monopoly and the need for government regulation duration. Rather than minimization of deadweight loss, i suggest that the primary rationale for natural monopoly regulation is the protection of sunk investments in particular, the sunk investments made by the customers of the regulated firm. The economic theory of regulation after a decade of deregulation. Natural monopoly and its regulation chicago unbound. It generally occurs without any unfair play or business practices that might stifle rivalry. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read natural monopoly and its regulation. Regulating natural monopolies os microeconomics 2e.
Posner a firm that is the only seller of a product or service having no close substitutes is said to enjoy a monopoly1 monopoly is an important concept to this article but even more important is the related but somewhat less. Second, the monopoly that results from realization of all economies is usually accompanied by public ownership or regulation, each of which has its own wellknown limitations with respect to cost minimization. Jason welker is available for tutoring, ib internal asse. Posner i shall reply briefly to the main points made in the comments, and i shall then address two additional issues, which were not adequately developed in my original article. Electricity was once seen as the textbook example of a monopoly good, due to its reliance on large, capitalintensive coal, nuclear, and hydroelectric power plants with declining marginal costs of. Technological progress technological developments have been the drive behind the transformation of certain natural monopoly markets to more competitive outcomes. In this way they are not only generally able to make supernormal profits and increase inequalities in income distribution but also cause inefficiency. This chapter examines some of the optimal policies that are used to control a natural monopoly.
Richard a posner natural monopolies exist in those markets in which demand can be satisfied at lowest cost by the output of only one rather than several competing firms. Regulation is designed to limit upside returns above the cost. Specifically, discuss the role of interest group politics in the creation and operation of the regulation at issue, making. Natural monopoly and its regulation ebook written by richard a. In small countries like new zealand, electricity transmission is a natural monopoly. The third, and crucial step in its critique of regulation is to question the assumptions of a benevolent and competent government. Natural monopolies exist in those markets in which demand can be satisfied at lowest cost by the output of only one rather than several competing firms. Points a, b, c, and f illustrate four of the main choices for regulation. The social costs of monopoly and regulation cameron economics. Posner, natural monopoly and its regulation 30th anniversary ed. Natural monopolies exist in those markets in which dem.
Posner i shall reply briefly to the main points made in the comments, and i shall then address two. Chapter 23 optimal policies for natural monopolies. Posner a firm that is the only seller of a product or service having no close substitutes is said to enjoy a monopoly. The social costs of monopoly and regulation richard a. What is the impact of the monopoly power on its customers. Natural monopoly and its regulation cato institute. Similarly, a comparison of intellectual property law and natural monopoly regulation provides a good rejoinder to the extravagant claim that, because intellectual property is just another species of property, deviations for full property rights roughly, fee simple should be suspect. Posner university of chicago law school and national bureau of economic research this paper presents a model and some highly tentative empirical estimates of the social costs of monopoly and monopoly inducing regulation in the united states.
A natural monopoly is a situation in which there cannot be more than one efficient provider of a good. It may already have had some intellectual impact in the recent white house recommendations for a competitive, unregulated structure for domestic satellites. Thirty years after its initial publication, read the original insights of richard posner about the regulation of natural monopoly as well as a new preface in which posner reflects on the. A firm that is the only seller of a product or service having no close sub stitutes is said to enjoy a. Natural monopoly real world monopolies describe an example of a realworld industry or market that would be considered by economists to be a natural monopoly. I shall reply briefly to the main points made in the comments, and i shall then address two. I suggest that the conventional economic rationale for natural monopoly regulation is flawed. Simultaneously with stigler, richard posner provided an important critique, and several years later he gave the theory its grandiose name. Introduction this chapter discusses two things, both related to the fact that, in the presence of a monopoly, there is less surplus generated in the market because of the existence of the monopoly.
A company simply takes advantage of certain conditions and creates a protective shield around its business operations. The economic theory of regulation after a decade of. What characteristics of the industry make it a monopoly. Thirty years ago a young professor named richard posner asked the provocative question of whether the existence of natural monopoly provides. Thirty years after its initial publication, read the original insights of richard posner about the regulation of natural monopoly as well as a new preface in which posner reflects on the deregulation of industries that has occurred since 1969 and the possibilities for more deregulation in the future. Due to large fixed costs and a small market size, one seller can serve the entire market at the downwardsloping section of its average cost curve, meaning that it will have lower average costs than any potential entrant. Natural monopoly and the need for government regulation.
Posner, natural monopoly and its regulation, 2i stan. Pdf chapter 16 regulation of natural monopoly researchgate. Read monopoly books like law and economics of vertical integration and control and the monopolists for free with a free 30day trial. With well functioning courts enforcing property rights and contracts. Under such conditions, conventional wisdom suggests that government regulation must substitute. The scope of price and entry regulation and its institutional infrastructure grew considerably during the first 75 years of the 20th century, covering additional industries, involving new and larger regulatory agencies, and. Theory of natural monopoly download ebook pdf, epub. But if the naturalmonopoly conditions havent faded entirely away and entry is. Posner university of chicago law school and national bureau of economic research this paper presents a model and some highly tentative empirical estimates of the social costs of monopoly and monopolyinducing regulation in the united states. Monopolists restrict output and raise price of their products. Posner a firm that is the only seller of a product or service having no close substitutes is said to enjoy a monopoly1 monopoly is an important concept tothis article but even more important is the related but somewhat lessfamiliar concept of natural monopoly. Early on, posner 1969 rightly noted that market power in the. Posner professor of law the university of chicago students of the regullated industries often assume that regulation is designed either to approximate the results of competition or to protect the regulated firms. An industry or market with one seller is known as a monopoly.
Meaning of monopoly what a monopolist does a monopolist is a firm that is the only producer of a good that has no close substitutes. Rate of return regulation makes sense for natural monopolies. The ability of a monopolist or other firm to raise its price above the competitive level by reducing output is known as market power. The question arises whether the same really can be said about an unregulated natural monopolist. The word monopoly has been derived from the combination of two words i. It is an industry where the minimum efficient scale is a large share of market demand such there is room for only one firm to fully exploit all of the available internal. Want to learn more about economics, or just be ready for an upcoming quiz, test or end of year exam. That is, the lerners index of monopoly power is nothing but the reciprocal of the numerical coefficient of priceelasticity of demand for the product, which supports our idea that the less elastic is the demand for the product, the more would. In this situation, competition might actually increase costs and prices. There are a few similarities between a monopoly and competitive market.
1591 773 376 968 411 893 1033 1626 461 1307 1645 1537 548 1603 1327 598 1028 554 1289 879 1385 590 1519 1072 1024 1548 1446 1006 210 746 140 1021 1316 545 605 715 457 641 1145